#1 is the correct. The rest can suck an egg
Also, didn't we learn this lesson last year
RDR was the highest reviewed game but God of War butchered it in the awards.
Likewise even though RE2 is the highest rated game, I won't be surprised if it's not the highest GoTY count winner because of how damn early it released in the year and how many websites won't remember that much about it come December.