Did you miss my GOTY list?
Posting it again, just in case.
1. The Last Of Us
2. Ni No Kuni
3. Grand Theft Auto V
Besides that, there is Tales of Xillia, Dragon's Crown, Puppeteer and Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance(Coming to PC next year) that i enjoyed a lot
If you want to count HD remixes on PS3, there is Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD remix and the upcoming 2.5 HD remix along with Final Fantasy X/X-2 HD that i am looking forward to.
I didn't enjoy Beyond Two Souls so i am not listing it here.
Edit: I missed the 2011-2012 stuff. Well..... i only got a PS3 last year so i can't say much here. Journey did win last year though