MULTI Baldur's Gate 3 released - 814K+ peak CCU on PC, Top Selling Pre-Order on US PSN

[CerebralTiger]

Crytek's previous work before Hunt Showdown was rated lower. So how are they tarnished? There will always be angles you haven't accounted for because you don't have any valid argument to begin with

Crytek was tarnished after Crysis 2 and then 3. Their status as Tarnished was under consideration after Hunt: Showdown, but then along came Crysis Remastered Trilogy like a ghost from the past

We all know why CerebralTiger hasn't posted BG3's metascore yet.

Same reason why Necrokiller hasn't shared it yet

Yes, I've been keeping tabs ever since

Reveal tou khud ho gaye

 

[Necrokiller]

Same reason why Necrokiller hasn't shared it yet

Because CerebralTiger has to tell us what his new criteria is. Lets see what he considers worthy of being "tarnished" in Larian's case

Reveal tou khud ho gaye

Ab khud reveal hogaye to aag kisi terhaan to bhujaani hai naaa

Poll theory = tarnished
Dark theme theory = tarnished
Post searching theory = tarnished

Crysis Remastered Trilogy

Allow me to throw your logic in the dust bin, yet again.

- Remaster isn't a new game
- It is NOT a full priced release - which was JUST listed as a criteria few posts before.

But if CerebralTiger chooses to die on this hill, lets go ahead and add a few new entries to the tarnished Hall of Shame:

Creative Business Unit 3
Housemarque
Platinum Games
Insomniac
Monolith Soft
Mercury Steam
Media Molecule
Team Ico
Kojima Productions

Atlus
Arc System Works
Capcom

Nope. Their past work = their most recent work

And this argument doesn't even work in case of CDPR, as before Cyberpunk 2077, CDPR released Thronebreaker which scored lower. Fitte mooo CerebralTiger

 

[CerebralTiger]

Poll theory = tarnished
Post searching theory = tarnished

Both have been proven

- It is NOT a full priced release - which was JUST listed as a criteria few posts before.

Oh right, I thought it was a $60 collection. Then, that puts Crytek in the grey list for now. If Crysis 4 gets a notable increase over Hunt: Showdown's Metascore, the studio shall be untarnished

And this argument doesn't even work in case of CDPR, as before Cyberpunk 2077, CDPR released Thronebreaker which scored lower.

It is NOT a full priced release - which was JUST listed as a criteria in your same post

 

[Necrokiller]

Both have been proven

Nope, all speculation because CerebralTiger is still mad about outing CTRON

It is NOT a full priced release - which was JUST listed as a criteria in your same post

But CerebralTiger just counted Crysis Remastered Trilogy as a valid game

Oh right, I thought it was a $60 collection.

Suuuuuuuuuuuuuuure you did, how irresponsible to be labeling studios like that, not the ones you like yourself ofcourse, without even making sure they qualify for it based on your own rules. tsk tsk

Creative Business Unit 3
Housemarque
Platinum Games
Insomniac
Monolith Soft
Mercury Steam
Media Molecule
Team Ico
Kojima Productions
Atlus
Arc System Works
Capcom

Too bad about Capcom, Atlus and Arc System Works. Ill be sure to update the Hall of Shame as I discover more of CerebralTiger's fav studios getting tarnished

And From Software is very likely getting adding to this list, unless CerebralTiger expects AC6 to score a 96+

 

[CerebralTiger]

Nope, all speculation because CerebralTiger is still mad about outing CTRON

Nope, I got all the evidence I needed

But CerebralTiger just counted Crysis Remastered Trilogy as a valid game

Human error is a thing

Too bad about Capcom, Atlus and Arc System Works. Ill be sure to update the Hall of Shame as I discover more of CerebralTiger's fav studios getting tarnished

Capcom, Atlus, and Arc System Works are publishers with multiple development studios. Just like CBU3 is one of several studios at Square Enix. I judge them independently based on their past work

And From Software is very likely getting adding to this list, unless CerebralTiger expects AC6 to score a 96+

See above. The AC6 team is led is Sekiro lead designer, while Miyazaki's team works on another project

 

[Necrokiller]

Nope, I got all the evidence I needed

Good. Many things can true in your reality, but thats not the one everyone is living in

Human error is a thing

But you're a tiger

Capcom, Atlus, and Arc System Works are publishers with multiple development studios. Just like CBU3 is one of several studios at Square Enix. I judge them independently based on their past work

Irrelevant. Just as "Capcom" is the one getting praised for some games, "Capcom" is the one who will get tarnished.

Which brings me to another addition in the Hall of Shame list:

Nintendo.

Thank you Pikmin 4

 

[CerebralTiger]

Irrelevant. Just as "Capcom" is the one getting praised for some games, "Capcom" is the one who will get tarnished.

Relevant as per my rules. Each development team is judged based on its previous work

Which brings me to another addition in the Hall of Shame list

See above. It was developed by the Pikmin studio within EPD, which previously worked on Pikmin 3 and the Pikmin 1+2 remaster

Feel free to inquire further regarding my rules. I'll be happy to clarify

 

[Necrokiller]

Pikmin studio

No such legal entity exists.

Like I said, your reality is not the one everyone is living in

 

[CerebralTiger]

Nintendo hasn't assigned names to individual development studios working under EPD, but it is known which team handles which IPs

 

[Necrokiller]

Nintendo hasn't assigned names to individual development studios working under EPD

And therefore, there is no such thing as a "Pikmin studio". The game is developed by Nintendo EPD.

And currently, they are in the tarnished bin

 

[CerebralTiger]

EPD development teams are in fact classified by Nintendo internally as EPD 1 to 11. They are distinct, individual teams working on separate projects (including R&D). This is well-known by anyone who knows a thing or two about Nintendo. Clearly not Necrokiller, then (outside of his secret admiration for Mario games)

 

[Necrokiller]

Internal matters are their own. Nintendo wants the world to know them as Nintendo EPD. Everybody knows that. Currently, they are tarnished

Oh, found another developer that is tarnished:

Creative Business Unit 3
Housemarque
Platinum Games
Insomniac
Monolith Soft
Mercury Steam
Media Molecule
Team Ico
Kojima Productions
Atlus
Arc System Works
Capcom
Nintendo
Vanillaware


-------------------------

Now if you're done with your shitposting, wait for the metascore to hit some arbitrary value that you are comfortable sharing.

Or sit this one out and find an excuse to play it on PS5

 

[CerebralTiger]

Internal matters are their own.

Nah I track their individual development teams. Your list continues to make incorrect additions, and doesn't play by my rules. Therefore, discarded. That will be all.

Now if you're done with your shitposting

HAHAHAHA shitposter invites me into thread with multiple shitposts, then blames me for shitposting

I have zero interest in games with snoozefest turn-based combat, regardless of the platform they are available on

 

[Necrokiller]

No one invited you. You just couldn't resist

@iampasha saaaeen, kese ho?

Spoiler: show

This is an invite

Nah I track their individual development teams. Your list continues to make incorrect additions

Well, its my list now. Just as you have your own

 

[CerebralTiger]

Why the hell not? Everyone is entitled to their own standards and rules

@iampasha saaaeen, kese ho?

Except this isn't the same as wondering if this game is a big enough deal for me when I had said that for a different game. altogether. Try a bit harder next time

 

[Necrokiller]

Except this isn't the same as wondering if this game is a big enough deal for me when I had said that for a different game. altogether. Try a bit harder next time

Not my fault you can't comprehend a rhetorical statement when evidence to the contrary is being posted. Try a bit harder next time

 

[CerebralTiger]

Dragging me into the discussion for an unrelated game is your fault

 

[Necrokiller]

Dragging

BUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

Like I said, not my fault you can't resist and feel like you're being "dragged"

 

[CerebralTiger]

Just like Necrokiller couldn't resist in the Tears of the Kingdom thread

 

[Necrokiller]

Just like Necrokiller couldn't resist in the Tears of the Kingdom thread

Except that I'm not whining like CerebralTiger for being "dragggged". Oh noes, the atroCiTy