MULTI [OT] Red Dead Redemption II | Wild West 1899

Necrokiller

Expert
Apr 16, 2009
13,573
5,128
129
You yourself commented on the NVidia image earlier in this page:

-Game does not top out at High, it has an Ultra setting too. This means, based on Nvidia recommendations, there is no single GPU that can run the game at 4K, Ultra and 60fps.

Seems like the game's either not that well optimized or Rockstar are pushing things way above the punching reach of the best GPUs in the market right now for the top-tier experience.

Understandable that people are mad that their $1200 GPUs can't even max out the game.
And?

Nothing I said passes any judgement on how well the game is optimised or it isn't. Not all game's "High" or "Ultra" mean the same thing. If the consoles are running at flat High settings and you need $1200 gpu to do 30fps on console resolutions, sure, its a shitty optimised game then.
 
Last edited:

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
Nothing I said passes any judgement on how well the game is optimised or it isn't. Not all game's "High" or "Ultra" mean the same thing. If the consoles are running at flat High settings and you need $1200 gpu to do 30fps, sure, its a shitty optimised game then.
My point was that keeping that in mind when you see PC gamers Abuses will lead to baning about the game in various performance threads, it shouldn't come as a surprise, whether it's a lack of optimization or pushing effects beyond the reach of the currently available hardware to max everything out.
 

Necrokiller

Expert
Apr 16, 2009
13,573
5,128
129
My point was that keeping that in mind when you see PC gamers Abuses will lead to baning about the game in various performance threads, it shouldn't come as a surprise, whether it's a lack of optimization or pushing effects beyond the reach of the currently available hardware to max everything out.
I mean you could Abuses will lead to ban about a game that isn't performing to your standards doesn't mean its justified like the guy faraany was talking about. He is whining that his Gtx 1060 cannot do 60fps at Ultra.
 

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
I mean you could Abuses will lead to ban about a game that isn't performing to your standards doesn't mean its justified like the guy faraany was talking about. He is whining that his Gtx 1060 cannot do 60fps at Ultra.
And like I said to franny, I wasn't even talking about that guy with my comment. The general PC performance thread is full of people saying the same thing.

People with 2080 Ti's are posting beautiful images in 4K with comments like 23-28 FPS. That's worse performance than the consoles.

Other people are posting how they're getting a game which looks and runs much worse on a 1050Ti than even a base PS4 (Keep in mind a 1050Ti is a far better GPU than the base PS4 GPU).

It's definitely not the best optimized game for sure.
 

Necrokiller

Expert
Apr 16, 2009
13,573
5,128
129
People with 2080 Ti's are posting beautiful images in 4K with comments like 23-28 FPS. That's worse performance than the consoles.
Do the settings match or exceed consoles?

It might as well as not be the best optimised game but your logic is hardly making any sense.
 

iampasha

Seasoned
Apr 4, 2013
2,756
1,475
129
28
Karachi
Ultra is too far fetched but a GTX 1060 6gb should be doing 60 fps at high settings 1080p. Which is still not the case here. After all it's no Crysis of this generation - there's no Ray tracing, no new revolutionary tech or anything behind this game... it's also a year late and still a terrible port.

No body should purchase this hack job. Let the crackers do their thing. Let Cockstar know that their are consequences for their lazy port. Just like PC gamers did with Arkham Knight

Sent from Mobile
 

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
Do the settings match or exceed consoles?

It might as well as not be the best optimised game but your logic is hardly making any sense.
Conveniently snipping the part of my post where a console comparison was made doesn't make my logic any less sound :p

A game not being able to max out it's in-game settings (not even counting any external mods) on the strongest / most expensive hardware available commercially right now should be unacceptable by any standards. This is Crysisgate all over again.
 

Necrokiller

Expert
Apr 16, 2009
13,573
5,128
129
Conveniently snipping the part of my post where a console comparison was made doesn't make my logic any less sound :p

A game not being able to max out it's in-game settings (not even counting any external mods) on the strongest / most expensive hardware available commercially right now should be unacceptable by any standards. This is Crysisgate all over again.
Conveniently not answering my question :p

Console comparison can only be made when you know what are the console equivalents. They sure as heck aint Ultra lol
 

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
Conveniently not answering my question :p

Console comparison can only be made when you know what are the console equivalents. They sure as heck aint Ultra lol
That 1050 Ti comment is a direct answer to your question.

PS4 is the most widely available console version, the PS4's custom GPU is roughly equivalent to RX 550. The RX 550 is about 100% slower than a 1050 Ti.

Here's the post on Resetera in question. 1050 Ti can't run the game at 1080p/ 30 FPS at the lowest settings. The lowest settings which look much worse than how the game looks on the base PS4.

-


Regardless of the settings, don't take my word on the game's buggy launch. Take these examples.




Red Dead Redemption 2 Is Having A Rough Launch On PC [Updated]


‘Red Dead Redemption 2’ PC launch hasn't had the best start


Red Dead Redemption 2 is broken on PC and no one knows how to fix it


RDR2: Launch issues megathread - Day Two








Abhi bhi koi comment karna hai farany ne ?
 

Necrokiller

Expert
Apr 16, 2009
13,573
5,128
129
That 1050 Ti comment is a direct answer to your question.
This was my question:
People with 2080 Ti's are posting beautiful images in 4K with comments like 23-28 FPS. That's worse performance than the consoles.
Do the settings match or exceed consoles?
Because you succeeded at pointing that 23-28fps is "worse performance than the consoles", but you failed to tell us the settings of those "beautiful 4K images".

Regardless of the settings, don't take my word on the game's buggy launch. Take these examples.
I don't think anyone claimed that the game isn't buggy at launch.

Here's the post on Resetera in question. 1050 Ti can't run the game at 1080p/ 30 FPS at the lowest settings. The lowest settings which look much worse than how the game looks on the base PS4.
That post doesn't even back up the claim with anything. Here you can see 1050Ti running the game at above 30fps on 1080p Medium.


Abhi bhi koi comment karna hai aap ne?
 
Last edited:

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
lol necro, that's an irrelevant question for what was posted.

That 4K images post is to show that the most expensive GPU in the market right now is struggling to hit 30 FPS (let alone 60) on the game at 4K. We don't know what settings the user was running, whether he was running everything at the max or what the equivalent Xbox X settings are. We will probably have more insight when Digital Foundry puts out their PC video.

Keep in mind this isn't even doing RTX. This is pure a pure non ray traced experience we're talking about.

However, what we do know is that the game's lower-end performance profile is worse than the base consoles. Hence the 1050 Ti vs PS4 comparison.

Not sure why you're even playing the devils advocate here.


That post doesn't even back up the claim with anything. Here you can see 1050Ti running the game at above 30fps on 1080p Medium.


Abhi bhi koi comment karna hai aap ne?

Yes, ask that guy to go to Saint Denis like the resteera poster said is the stress point (y)
 
Last edited:

Necrokiller

Expert
Apr 16, 2009
13,573
5,128
129
That 4K images post is to show that the most expensive GPU in the market right now is struggling to hit 30 FPS (let alone 60) on the game at 4K.
That's not relevant to the game's optimization, this is what you can't understand. Plenty of games considered "well optimized" struggle to maintain 60fps on their absolute highest settings at 4K. Throw in MSAA (which Red Dead 2 supports, and you don't know the settings so maybe that explains the performance) and games in general will even struggle to maintain 30fps. I think more than anything else that just proves that 4K is still a waste of resources, and thus investing in a 4K display is a waste of money.


Hence the 1050 Ti vs PS4 comparison.

Not sure why you're even playing the devils advocate here.
And the video I posted does prove that 1050Ti can handle Medium easily, when you said it cannot even do Low based on a random Era post. I wouldn't have to play devils advocate if you showed some logic in your claims.
 
Last edited:

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
That's not relevant to the game's optimization, this is what you can't understand. Plenty of games considered "well optimized" struggle to maintain 60fps on their absolute highest settings at 4K. I think more than anything else that just proves that 4K is still a waste of resources, and thus investing in a 4K display is a waste of money.
Struggle to maintain 60 FPS sure, but we're talking about 23~28 FPS here. 60 is a pipe dream at that resolution and those settings on the worlds most expensive / technologically advanced GPU right now.

And the video I posted does prove that 1050Ti can handle Medium easily. I wouldn't have to play devils advocate if you made showed some sound logic in your claims.
Read the edit.

Most benchmarks are from the prologue and/or barren areas.

The Era poster is talking about benching in Saint Denis.






"1050Ti needs 900p at low to reach 30 frames per second"


2:50:59 mark.



I accept your apology. (y)
 

Necrokiller

Expert
Apr 16, 2009
13,573
5,128
129
Struggle to maintain 60 FPS sure, but we're talking about 23~28 FPS here. 60 is a pipe dream at that resolution and those settings on the worlds most expensive / technologically advanced GPU right now.
You just said you don't know the settings for those screenshots. Maybe they are with MSAA enabled? Why are you so quick to make these conclusions?



4K, Ultra, 43fps

I accept your apology (y)

I accept your apology.
I accept yours too
 
Last edited:

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
You just said you don't know the settings for those screenshots. Maybe they are with MSAA enabled? Why are you so quick to make these conclusions?
I clearly said we don't know what settings they're using. However 23~28 FPS is not acceptable on a console game, let alone the most expensive GPU in the market.


I accept yours too (y)

There's no St Denis footage in that video Necro :laugh1:

Just take the L and leave it at that.





edit: caught you before the edit :laugh1::laugh1:
 

Chandoo

Resi Evil 4 > Your fav game.
Jan 19, 2007
45,625
2,201
129
S.S Normandy
Speaking of taking the L
What 23-28fps?

Abhi bhi you'll keep shit posting based on claims you can't even back up from Era ? :laugh1:

Is that better or worse than posting a video then quickly deleting it after realizing how it proved you wrong, and then re-adding it to save face after you've been caught



This is the post in question where the user says 23~28 FPS.


Now please share a 1050Ti 1080p Medium video in St. Denis which can easily do 30 FPS and don't delete it this time
 

iampasha

Seasoned
Apr 4, 2013
2,756
1,475
129
28
Karachi
Take the L ? Is it Lun or loss

*You have entered the comedy area*

I know, I Know, I'm funny please laugh now



Sent from Mobile
 
General chit-chat
Help Users
IMPORTANT: Please Change Your Passwords to avoid being botted. | Click for Discord
  • No one is chatting at the moment.
  • GloriousChicken GloriousChicken:
    Everyone, please change your passwords.
    Link
  • Necrokiller Necrokiller:
    The only valid thing from his pov he said in the video is AC dead since Black Flag. According to woke police that game was woke too. Welsh man in West Indies. So atleast he's consistent I guess lol
    Link
  • Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    Necrokiller said:
    It's based on an actual real life person so I don't think the woke police have a valid case here.
    Nope. They have a very valid case. The above video explains it all.
    Link
  • Necrokiller Necrokiller:
    It's based on an actual real life person so I don't think the woke police have a valid case here.
    • Like
    Reactions: SolitarySoldier
    Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    Meanwhile Ghost of Tsushima PC version is out now. Looks 100 times better than ASS Creed already.
    Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    Did y'all see the new Assassin's Creed trailer? They finally made a AC set in Japan & then they put a negro as the male protagonist. Ubisoft is taking cues from Disney, and it isn't gonna end well for them, just like Disney. Go woke, go broke!
    Link
  • Necrokiller Necrokiller:
    First Fallout 4 update and now this 🤡
    Link
  • Necrokiller Necrokiller:
    MS and Bethesda continuing their streak of massive Ls 😬
    Link
  • Link
  • funky funky:
    Hello
    Link
  • NaNoW NaNoW:
    by closing down good studios
    Link
  • NaNoW NaNoW:
    well he is breaking barriers
    • Like
    Reactions: KetchupBiryani
    Link
  • iampasha iampasha:
    SolitarySoldier said:
    Phil keeps talking about breaking barriers to gaming, making it accessible on all platforms yada yada, while killing competition and creativity at the same time. the fact that i actually believed him for a second lol
    guys the biggest yapper in the Industry right now. All he do is yap
    Link
  • Necrokiller Necrokiller:
    Phil should be held responsible for this shitfest too, just like Sarah, but it's highly likely that these decisions are coming from Satya. And this isn't even the end of it. More closures are coming.
    Link
  • SolitarySoldier SolitarySoldier:
    if we are moving towards more and more popular trash across platforms that make billions for companies, I'm happy with all the barriers and exclusivity because at least that brings some pressure to create good stuff.
    Link
  • SolitarySoldier SolitarySoldier:
    Phil keeps talking about breaking barriers to gaming, making it accessible on all platforms yada yada, while killing competition and creativity at the same time. the fact that i actually believed him for a second lol
    Link
  • SolitarySoldier SolitarySoldier:
    "These changes are not a reflection of the creativity and skill of the talented individuals at these teams or the risks they took to try new things" ... seems to me that's exactly what it is
    Link
  • SolitarySoldier SolitarySoldier:
    why make good games when u can just buy everyone and shut them down lol
    Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    I'm gonna say one last time, F*** Microsoft to infinity!
    Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    Microsoft deserves all the hate they can get. Seriously i can't explain how much i want to curse them out.
    Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    They could've sold the studios instead of closing them, but the nazi bastards just didn't want competition down the road.
    Link
  • Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    F*** Microsoft, and F*** their fanboys.
    Link
  • XPremiuM XPremiuM:
    What's the f*** is wrong with them? I mean really? Have they completely lost it? F***ing retards.
    Link
    GloriousChicken GloriousChicken: Everyone, please change your passwords.