OOohhh I'm not the only one! I reverted back to PTCL about five days back (last Friday), and yes - it is unbelievable how I find their hard product much better than Nayatel (which has a far, far better soft product - things that I don't use).
PTCL charges for phone and TV in that price. 400 rupees analog + 400 for HD (which means 800 per month) + 25Mbps for 2800 = 3600 per month (excluding tax, and assuming you don't use their landline). On PTCL, you get the same thing for ~3400. Nayatel would be a bit cheaper if you opt for 20 Mbps.
However, if you only take Nayatel's internet ONLY, then it's definitely cheaper. PTCL doesn't offer single play.
I have the MiBox S - I didn't want to purchase additional equipment from Nayatel, so I used their app. SD channels were fine, but HD channels were out of sync (and that appeared to be a transmission issue since it didn't happen with all HD channels). I didn't complain - I used their free trial to see if I needed it or not. The number of channels you got were not bad - but tbh, I have an IPTV subscription with channels from all over the world + TV guide + some catchup on some, so...that's what I did (my own IPTV + Nayatel + phone).
With PTCL, I couldn't care less about their TV, but it's there :/
NOW - when Nayatel would route the traffic on PIE, everything worked (almost) fine. The instant a data packet goes through Transworld, it would get choked. Testing with another forum member seemed to hint that TW has blocked UDP packets for some ports - but TCP would work. Wireguard = UDP. IKEv2 = UDP. Both are faster than OpenVPN's UDP... but they're all blocked unless you use a standard port. And their changing policy put me off (they first switched IPs, not subnets... then they said I need Optimus... then they said I needed static IP (which was far, far too expensive since they only give that to corporates)). So - unfortunately, Nayatel is not for us - not because of Nayatel, but because of Transworld.
Oh, and PTCL tends to load Telegram's website more often than not (but not always).
But where PTCL sucks? Their customer service feels like you're talking to a robot. Nayatel's like you're talking to a human. That, unfortunately, didn't matter much for me since I don't chat up their reps and want a working service.
VDSL isn't that bad. Sure the uploads are halved but... I don't know what your requirements are for uploading, but it's not that bad. Stormfiber, I read in another thread, is back on TW so good luck with VPNs. Unless you figure a way around the block.